Conner Insurance provides comprehensive commercial, personal, and benefits insurance solutions coverage for people and businesses in all 50 U.S. states. In addition, we understand a company’s most valuable asset is its people, which is why we become your partner, advisor, and supporter. Insurance is complicated, and our team makes the process simple and effective. Schedule a consultation with one of our trusted insurance advisors to learn how our full-service agency can meet your business needs, reduce risk, and maximize your company culture.

Benefits Programs


Valuable benefit plans that protect your employees and their families.

Learn More
Commercial Insurance


Our robust insurance solutions cover the entire spectrum of commercial risk management.

Learn More
Personal Insurance


Insurance policies protect your home, assets, and your loved ones.

Learn More

In the News

Personal and Commercial Insurance Company

Who We Are

  • Family-owned for over 70 years
  • Awarded "Best Places to Work in Indiana" six times
  • Finalist for Healthiest Employer of Indiana nine times
  • CEO Ben Conner recognized in Indiana Business Journal 2021’s Forty Under 40.
  • Highly qualified trusted insurance advisors with specific areas of expertise.
  • Mission-driven, relationship-minded, culture-centered, health-conscious business.
  • About Us

What People Say

Conner Insurance has set the standard for superior guidance and exceptional service for more than 70 years.

Casiana Warfield

My husband and I are first-time home buyers and Ashley took the time to walk us through the home insurance process. She is timely and personable. I can rest easy knowing our policy is comprehensive but also affordable.

Ellie Orzeske

Brooke was great! She answered quickly and was extremely helpful throughout the process. She was able to save us over $500 a year on our policies. Would highly recommend her!

Erik Cooper

We finally found a health insurance partner that we trust and that goes to bat for our company.

  • Benefits Programs. Fully-Insured, self-insured, and captive solutions for medical, dental, vision, and more.
  • Employee Benefits. Medical, dental, vision, and disability insurance options for companies big and small.
  • Benefits Strategy & Planning. Comprehensive data analytics, population management, and other tools to help your program operate efficiently and improve your bottom line.
  • Human Resources Consulting & Strategy. Attract, recruit, and retain talent while creating a world-class company culture.

Contact Us

At Conner Insurance, we want to be your insurance provider of choice. We offer full-service insurance and HR consulting to individuals and businesses in all 50 U.S. states. Contact us at (317) 808-7711 to speak to an advisor, get a quote, or schedule a consultation with one of our professionals.

2017 Healthiest Employers