Homeowners Insurance

Homeowners & Rental Homes

Is your primary residence or investment property appropriately insured? At Conner Insurance, we’ve insured homes and rental properties for nearly 70 years. You can feel safe when you have a homeowners insurance question or claim, knowing we’ll continue to be here. Contact us at (317) 808-7711 to speak to a representative.

Personal Insurance Plans

Individual Insurance Advisors

We partner with more than 20 carriers, which allows us to find you the right coverage at the best rate. Cover all your personal assets with our wide array of personal insurance plans.

Rental Home Insurance

Protect Your Home and Investments

Whatever property you own, we can find the best homeowners insurance at the best rates available to you.

  • Primary residence
  • Rental home and landlord insurance
  • Investment property

We can handle policies for specialty situations, too? Ask us about coverage for:

  • Using your home as an Airbnb or short-term rental property. Protect your investment against wear-and-tear and unruly guests while you minimize risk.
  • Short-term housing for college students. Cover your student’s property and liability for a semester or whatever length of time you need.
  • Multiple and multi-family properties. More than one rental property or multi-family structures.
  • Builder’s risk. Make sure you’re covered during home renovations.

It varies for everyone. Typically, clients get enough coverage for the structure and the replacement cost for personal belongings. We’ll review your situation and compare your existing policy if you have one to see where changes may be necessary.

Even the best homeowners insurance limits coverage to the structure, corresponding damage, and personal items. If certain home components, such as sewer lines or major appliances cause issues, those aren’t covered. However, you can get separate home warranties and service line endorsements to cover everything.

Yes! Talk to one of our insurance advisors about possible discounts for multiple policies, such as auto, boat, or any other coverage obtained through Conner. You can also achieve discounts through home improvements such as a new roof, alarm system installation, and more.

Request a Quote Today

"*" indicates required fields


Other Types of Insurance

We’re a full-service company that offers a wide selection of insurance and services, including:

Serving Indiana and Beyond

Conner Insurance has been in business for over 70 years and through three family generations. We’re locally owned and serve multiple cities in Indiana, including Carmel, Westfield, Fishers, Indianapolis, and Brownsburg. However, we partner with more than 20 carriers to provide comprehensive policies for people in all 50 U.S. states. Contact us at (317) 808-7711 to request a quote.

Personal Insurance Team

Todd Hufford Conner Insurance

Todd Hufford

Chief Operating Officer
Ashley Brown Conner Insurance

Ashley Brown

Personal Advisor
Brooke Starling Conner Insurance

Brooke Starling

Personal Advisor
Tony Wilcox Conner Insurance

Tony Wilcox

Personal Advisor
Joe Thompson Conner Insurance

Joe Thompson

Personal Advisor
Abby Robey Conner Insurance

Abby Robey

Senior Account Manager
Adinda Webster Conner Insurance

Adinda Webster

Account Manager
Alyssa Gable Conner Insurance

Alyssa Gable

Personal Lines Manager / Applied EPIC Administrator
Amy Jones Conner Insurance

Amy Jones

Account Manager
Christine Taylor Conner Insurance

Christine Taylor

Account Manager
Dereka Woods Conner Insurance

Dereka Woods

Claims Advocate
Elizabeth La Lond Conner Insurance

Elizabeth La Lond

Account Manager
Nicole Northcutt Conner Insurance

Nicole Northcutt

Account Manager
Shannon Morris Conner Insurance

Shannon Morris

Advisor Assistant
Skyler Hughes Conner Insurance

Skyler Hughes

Advisor Assistant
Brynn Cochran Conner Insurance

Brynn Cochran

Personal Advisor
Jennelle Hegnauer Conner Insurance

Jennelle Hegnauer

Account Manager
Valerie Boyland  Conner Insurance

Valerie Boyland

Account Manager
Tara Dowson-Park Conner Insurance

Tara Dowson-Park

Account Manager

What People Say

Conner Insurance has set the standard for superior guidance and exceptional service for more than 70 years.

Cheryl Wood

Association of Christian Schools International

We always look forward to new ideas from Conner Insurance to help us improve our benefits and contain costs. The Conner team brings a different perspective, energy, and commitment to designing a benefits program for our non-profit ministry and is a pleasure to work with.

Aaron Robertson

HandledNow LLC

Conner seems to be proactive in their approach to communication about anything we need to be aware of. Everyone we work with at Conner seems to care about the success of our business.

Craig Freyenberger

Baptist Children's Home

Conner Insurance excels at informing us of the current market conditions and how that might affect us. The Conner team contacts us regularly and visit us, even though we are hours away! Conner now has a local account representative which is great. Conner is a resource we use frequently to bounce ideas off.

2017 Healthiest Employers

Home / Homeowners & Rental Homes