Insurance Company

Who We Are

At Conner Insurance, we understand risk and benefits. We also understand culture. Our understanding, experience, and specialized skills make us who we are. Our mission at Conner is to build relationships, solve problems, serve people, and pursue excellence. Contact us at (317) 808-7711 to speak to an advisor.

Contact Us

Our Values

Honor God in what we say, think, and do.

Deliver strategies and products that protect people and our clients’ assets, budgets and EBITDA.

Pursue innovation and challenge the status quo.

Simplify insurance for the end user.

Serve teammates and customers with integrity, grace, and selflessness.

Treat everyone as family with transparency and kindness.

Insurance Company

Our History

Henry Clay Conner Jr. founded Conner Insurance in 1949 after attending school through Aetna Insurance after serving the U.S. in WWII. He started the business in a mall basement and grew the firm into what it is today.

Initially, Conner Insurance offered property and casualty and life insurance. Through quality service, emphasis on relationships, and innovative design, the company shaped itself into the business it is today.

Our Culture

At Conner Insurance, we aim to stay healthy, have fun, and build a better work environment. We practice what we preach, so these things are important to us, and we know they’re important to you. That’s why we make ourselves available 24/7.

We promote a warm, supporting work environment that is collaborative, competitive, and focused on developing relationships. We offer the same experienced services we deliver to our clients with our focus on maintaining healthy lifestyles and supporting culture.

Our employees enjoy Team Appreciation outings, friendly office competitions, and team rallies. We stress the importance of communication and have a holistic view of wellness. Our efforts have resulted in several workplace awards such as Healthiest Employers of Indiana, Best Places to Work in Indiana, and many others.

Conner is a family-owned business that has operated for more than 70 years. We view all our team members as part of our family. Our work environment reflects the extraordinary level of service we provide to the clients we serve. We seek high-quality candidates to join our high-quality business.

Employee Insurance Company

Insurance We Provide

Benefits Programs Company


Learn More
Commercial Insurance Company


Learn More
Personal Insurance Company


Learn More

Contact Us

Located in central Indiana, Conner Insurance serves the entire state including Carmel, Westfield, Fishers, Indianapolis, and Brownsburg, but also provides insurance and benefits to all 50 states. Contact us at (317) 808-7711 to learn more.

What People Say

Conner Insurance has set the standard for superior guidance and exceptional service for more than 70 years.

Samantha Contreras

Life Science Innovations

The Conner team is great to work with. They are knowledgeable, provide solid advice and are a very favorable partnership. They are the perfect extension to our team.

Erik Cooper

CRF Affordable Housing, Inc.

We finally found a health insurance partner that we trust and that goes to bat for our company.

Jessica Lahr

Pathfinder Services

Ben and his team are very knowledgeable. They listen to what we want and make it happen. They are great!

2017 Healthiest Employers

Home / Who We Are