Personal Insurance Plans

Having adequate personal insurance coverage gives you peace of mind. Live stress-free knowing all of the things you value most are covered, regardless of what life brings your way. At Conner Insurance, our personal insurance advisors work with you to determine what individual insurance best meets your unique needs. Contact us at (317) 808-7711 to speak to a professional.

Homeowners and Rental Insurance Plans

Homeowners & Rental Insurance

Insure your personal home, vacation home, Airbnb, and even niche properties.

Learn More
Home Warranty and Service Insurance Plans

Home Warranties & Service Line Insurance

Protect what general homeowners insurance doesn’t so that you don’t get caught unexpected.

Learn More
Renters Insurance Plans

Renters Insurance

Make sure your personal items and liability are insured as a renter.

Learn More
Automobile Insurance Plans

Automobile Insurance

Choose from competitive car insurance rates, safe driver programs, and more.

Learn More
Motorcycle Insurance Plans

Motorcycle Insurance

Get motorcycle coverage that changes with the riding season.

Learn More
Boat Insurance Plans

Boat Insurance

Find the right boat insurance and personal watercraft policies.

Learn More
RV and Motorhome Insurance Plans

RV & Motorhome Insurance

Make sure your RV investment is effectively protected.

Learn More
Pet Insurance Plans

Pet Insurance

Pet insurance gives your furry friend health coverage, too.

Learn More
Life and Long-term Care Insurance Plans

Life & Long-term Care Insurance

Protect your family and insure your long-term care.

Learn More
Umbrella Insurance Plans

Umbrella Insurance

Cover the unknowns and prevent catastrophic loss.

Learn More
Niche Insurance Plans

Other Personal Insurances

Safeguard your valuables, jewelry, and even special events.

Learn More
Individual Health Insurance Plans

Personal Health Insurance

Taking care of your health is the most important thing you can do.

Learn More

Request a Quote Today

"*" indicates required fields


Personal Insurance Plans

Individual Insurance Advisors

We partner with more than 20 carriers, which allows us to find you the right coverage at the best rate. Cover all your personal assets with our wide array of personal insurance plans.

Other Types of Insurance Policies

At Conner Insurance, we understand risk, business, people, and the importance of culture. It defines your company, and it makes us who we are, too. Enjoy the benefits of a personal advisor and a one-stop shop for all your insurance needs. Aside from personal insurance, we offer commercial insurance & services and a robust menu of benefits programs, including employee benefits and human resource consulting and strategy.

Request a Quote

At Conner Insurance, our insurance policies and solutions are as unique as you. You can expect to speak to someone who listens to your situation, reviews the entirety of your assets and risk, and helps you identify coverage custom-tailored to your specific needs. In addition to Indiana, all other U.S. states can contact us online, or give us a call at (317) 808-7711 if you’re in Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, or nearby.

Personal Insurance Team

Todd Hufford Conner Insurance

Todd Hufford

Chief Operating Officer
Ashley Brown Conner Insurance

Ashley Brown

Personal Advisor
Brooke Starling Conner Insurance

Brooke Starling

Personal Advisor
Tony Wilcox Conner Insurance

Tony Wilcox

Personal Advisor
Joe Thompson Conner Insurance

Joe Thompson

Personal Advisor
Abby Robey Conner Insurance

Abby Robey

Senior Account Manager
Adinda Webster Conner Insurance

Adinda Webster

Account Manager
Alyssa Gable Conner Insurance

Alyssa Gable

Personal Lines Manager / Applied EPIC Administrator
Amy Jones Conner Insurance

Amy Jones

Account Manager
Christine Taylor Conner Insurance

Christine Taylor

Account Manager
Dereka Woods Conner Insurance

Dereka Woods

Claims Advocate
Elizabeth La Lond Conner Insurance

Elizabeth La Lond

Account Manager
Nicole Northcutt Conner Insurance

Nicole Northcutt

Account Manager
Shannon Morris Conner Insurance

Shannon Morris

Advisor Assistant
Skyler Hughes Conner Insurance

Skyler Hughes

Advisor Assistant
Brynn Cochran Conner Insurance

Brynn Cochran

Personal Advisor
Jennelle Hegnauer Conner Insurance

Jennelle Hegnauer

Account Manager
Valerie Boyland  Conner Insurance

Valerie Boyland

Account Manager
Tara Dowson-Park Conner Insurance

Tara Dowson-Park

Account Manager

What People Say

Conner Insurance has set the standard for superior guidance and exceptional service for more than 70 years.

Cheryl Wood

Association of Christian Schools International

We always look forward to new ideas from Conner Insurance to help us improve our benefits and contain costs. The Conner team brings a different perspective, energy, and commitment to designing a benefits program for our non-profit ministry and is a pleasure to work with.

Aaron Robertson

HandledNow LLC

Conner seems to be proactive in their approach to communication about anything we need to be aware of. Everyone we work with at Conner seems to care about the success of our business.

Craig Freyenberger

Baptist Children's Home

Conner Insurance excels at informing us of the current market conditions and how that might affect us. The Conner team contacts us regularly and visit us, even though we are hours away! Conner now has a local account representative which is great. Conner is a resource we use frequently to bounce ideas off.

2017 Healthiest Employers

Home / Personal Insurance Plans